Looking to get antenna to take place of Imax2000.Is Maco 5/8 better than Workman W-58 ?

i asked about those antenas .
maco V-58 vs. workman W-58

__________________
Frank Zappa observed, "It's not getting any smarter out there. You have to come to terms with stupidity, and make it work for you."

Probably the same but who wants to be the test subject?

Can't tell you which is 'best'. I would have to agree with others in that a '5/8'wave antenna is a '5/8'wave antenna, about the only 'big' difference is in the mechanical construction. Which is stronger, or lasts longer in the weather you expect it to 'live' in? I can't tell you that one either, too many variables involved. Compare them by weight? Heavier means stronger? Beats me, lots of variables in that too (packing?). Cost? Oooo, I ain't going there, especially the way the economy is now!
Good luck!
- 'Doc

Thanks to all,I will try one and let you all know witch one I try.

The Workman W-58 the entire unit is better quality tested them both the workman had thicker meterials and stainless bolts and all the tubing was deburred, mechanical construction was far better should hold up better,they work about the same.

WOW !!!!
the workman is less than $80 shipped from palco .
W-58 Omni-Directional Antenna - Palco Electronics

__________________
Frank Zappa observed, "It's not getting any smarter out there. You have to come to terms with stupidity, and make it work for you."

Thank you Booty for the post. I just got the answer on what antenna will replace my old 1/2 GP. I have been debating a-99 vs IMAX for the past 6 months, but I could not bring myself to replace aluminum with fiberglass.

__________________
Secret Squirrel

"Keeper of Antiquated CB Technology"