Just went through the decision cycle between these two radios and thought that I would share why I reached one conclusion instead of another.
First, thank you all for the input, particularly Moleculo. Hands down, WorldWideDX was the most useful forum in terms of making the best decision. So good that I just paid my $15 and recommend that you do the same.
What I Wanted
- Go-kit Usability: Radio for my BoB that could get out in a variety of different ways in the event of an emergency
- APRS: Opportunity to experiment, passively experience traffic
- Pairing: Options for a two-radio solution for my wife to have in her BoB
- Travel: Easy to drop into a carry-on for travel
- PC Compatibility: How easily can it connect to a PC and how much functionality will I get once I connect it
To evaluate the radios, I read both user manuals, a whole pile of reviews, watched a dozen YouTube videos, and did a side-by-side evaluation at HRO.
Go Kit
VX-8DR by a mile. More durable, two more bands for Tx, wider Rx, band scope, and frequency counter.
APRS
D72A here. No mistake about it, the D72A is an APRS radio with a number of functions not available on any other HT. The PC-accessible TNC is a nice add also, creating a radio that will see its functionality increase more significantly over time. Not too far away from a true iPad/HT solution.
Pairing
VX-8DR, but shouldn’t be this close. Getting the wife a VX-8GR so that I can track her down. This should be a clear win for Yaesu, but oddly, it isn’t. The programming software doesn’t match and many of the accessories don’t match. If it wasn’t for ARTS, it would be a flat toss-up
Travel
VX-8DR. Again, two additional bands offer greater reach. Also, the spectrum analyzer, Smart Search and Channel Counter features give you options for tracking down strong signals if you are in a new town without your repeater guide.
Also, the flexible 24-bank memory allows you 14 more possible tags for geo’s outside your home territory.
PC Compatibility
By a mile to the D72A. The accessible TNC means that you can actually do things with the radio when you are connected to a PC. Add in that it uses a USB cable, developers can create iPad/Droid applications that will further enhance the value of the solution.
Winner (With Exceptions)
For me, VX-8DR.
Although the VX-8DR is ostensibly the cheaper radio ($420 vs. $450), for apples-to-apples functionality, the Kenwood will always be less expensive for the same features. Integrated GPS (+$100), software and cable (+$60), and 1800mAh battery (+$20) put you into the $600 range to really get you into the same ballpark (depending upon how you price out 222 MHz and the 6 meter band)
Thank you all for the help. Have the radio along with the Mic, GPS, 1800 mAh battery, AAA battery case, software/cable, and an MH-510 antenna
73,
AH
First, thank you all for the input, particularly Moleculo. Hands down, WorldWideDX was the most useful forum in terms of making the best decision. So good that I just paid my $15 and recommend that you do the same.
What I Wanted
- Go-kit Usability: Radio for my BoB that could get out in a variety of different ways in the event of an emergency
- APRS: Opportunity to experiment, passively experience traffic
- Pairing: Options for a two-radio solution for my wife to have in her BoB
- Travel: Easy to drop into a carry-on for travel
- PC Compatibility: How easily can it connect to a PC and how much functionality will I get once I connect it
To evaluate the radios, I read both user manuals, a whole pile of reviews, watched a dozen YouTube videos, and did a side-by-side evaluation at HRO.
Go Kit
VX-8DR by a mile. More durable, two more bands for Tx, wider Rx, band scope, and frequency counter.
APRS
D72A here. No mistake about it, the D72A is an APRS radio with a number of functions not available on any other HT. The PC-accessible TNC is a nice add also, creating a radio that will see its functionality increase more significantly over time. Not too far away from a true iPad/HT solution.
Pairing
VX-8DR, but shouldn’t be this close. Getting the wife a VX-8GR so that I can track her down. This should be a clear win for Yaesu, but oddly, it isn’t. The programming software doesn’t match and many of the accessories don’t match. If it wasn’t for ARTS, it would be a flat toss-up
Travel
VX-8DR. Again, two additional bands offer greater reach. Also, the spectrum analyzer, Smart Search and Channel Counter features give you options for tracking down strong signals if you are in a new town without your repeater guide.
Also, the flexible 24-bank memory allows you 14 more possible tags for geo’s outside your home territory.
PC Compatibility
By a mile to the D72A. The accessible TNC means that you can actually do things with the radio when you are connected to a PC. Add in that it uses a USB cable, developers can create iPad/Droid applications that will further enhance the value of the solution.
Winner (With Exceptions)
For me, VX-8DR.
Although the VX-8DR is ostensibly the cheaper radio ($420 vs. $450), for apples-to-apples functionality, the Kenwood will always be less expensive for the same features. Integrated GPS (+$100), software and cable (+$60), and 1800mAh battery (+$20) put you into the $600 range to really get you into the same ballpark (depending upon how you price out 222 MHz and the 6 meter band)
Thank you all for the help. Have the radio along with the Mic, GPS, 1800 mAh battery, AAA battery case, software/cable, and an MH-510 antenna
73,
AH