Tarheel screwdriver comparrison to steel whip

[nfsus]

I bought a screwdriver antenna that I've not installed yet because I've not out the rig in the truck yet. But right now I use 10m off of a 102" whip and it works great. I wonder what the comparrison between the two looks like? Or do I need to run both antennas? Just wonderin if anyone has tried both yet to see if the screwdriver compares. I dont think it would come close myself.

 

[w9cll]

The Tarheel will tune better but the performance will be nearly the same. I didn't run a Tarheel but I used a High Serria Screwdriver, I replaced the whip that it came with for a 72" one. Tuning was better as was the performance on the lower bands.

 

[fourstringburn]

I would run just the Tarheel.

Having a remote tune-able antenna is far more versatile than the slight edge in performance with a 102 whip on 10m.

I use a 5ft. whip on my Little Tarheel HP and it will tune down to 60 meters.

When stationary, I use a telescoping 17ft whip and have a full 1/4 wave on 20m and much better performance on the lower bands down to 80m.

At 6ft or more on the Tarheel, you'll start to lose 6m and even 10m if you go too long but that's the trade off to get better performance on the lower bands.

 

[nfsus]

I dont 6m. I never hear anything on 6m. Ever. I mention ever? So I do some 2m, 10, 20, 40, 80