Jays I10k or the Coily Excalibur

[Porkchop]

I'm looking to upgrade my antenna in the near future,but I'm torn between these 2. They're both a step up from the Sirio I have at the moment,so I would like some honest pros and cons.Is the Coily easier to set up?If so, how difficult is the I10k to set up?Rx,Tx....you know,the usual questions.
I look forward to some honest answers/recommendations,etc!
Cheers! 8)

 

[EDUK8TR]

Porkchop,

Here is some more food for thought. Wolf Radio .64 wave
I have been using this one for several years now and have been very satisfied with its performance.

 

[KingCobra_CDX882]

Happy New Years

It is Simple

Buy Jay's Interceptor I-10K

there is no contest..

if money is too tight then i would say WolfRadio .64

Do yourself a Huge Favor
Get the Interceptor I-10K 5/8 wave Ground Plane
It is First to None

Later

 

[Porkchop]

hmmm,i've been reading great reports about both,but i think i may be leaning towards jays product.
cheers for your input
happy new year.

 

[Master Chief]

Only one of these antennas allows you to adjust frequency AND impeadance. The I-10K.

 

[Thestonerguy]

hmmm,i've been reading great reports about both,but i think i may be leaning towards jays product.
cheers for your input
happy new year.

There isn't a better antenna on the market than Jay's...and it will last a lifetime.

 

[44 in the desert]

I'am slightly one sided about this subject, but I'll tell you this I put 9500 on the forward side of my Interceptor and get less than 5 watts reflected using a 10 watt slug!!! {probably imperfections in coax} I've yet to see any antenna do that, most of em just burn !!!! Steve A-1 antennas

 

[W5LZ]

...9500 watts? Really?
- 'Doc

 

[44 in the desert]

yeah really, when we say tested at 10 g's that for real... and that's 2nd gear... Of coarse thats for testing only, right?

 

[bob85]

where are you in the uk porkchop?, i am near pontefract a couple of miles from the m62, if you want to see an i10k close up your welcome to come and have a look at mine if your passing, sorry i dont have a coily base antenna to show you, a picture may be worth a thousand words but theres nothing like seeing it with your own eyes
,

 

[Porkchop]

Cheers mate.I'm down in Leicester,so I'm not in your neck of the woods very often,but if I'm planning a trip out that way,I'll give you a shout.
Cheers. 8)