• You can now help support WorldwideDX when you shop on Amazon at no additional cost to you! Simply follow this Shop on Amazon link first and a portion of any purchase is sent to WorldwideDX to help with site costs.

More FCC whackiness - now they're affecting potential EmComms

Sorry, but FCC can't "take" the 10 Meter band. There is a pesky ITU treaty the the US signed. Sure, they could prevent amateurs from using it, but because it is reserved for use by treaty, they couldn't just re-assigned it in the US for something else. Leastwise, that's the way I understand it.

CWM

First off, the FCC doesn't care about the law. They think they are the law, at least when it comes to communications. Second, you misread the post. I said that maybe they leave only the 10 meters for Amateurs. In any event, it was facetious since the old timer Amateurs working in the FCC are not about to let the FCC take away any Amateur frequencies.
 
The FCC are the enforcers of communications law in the USA. While they do not make the laws, they are free to implement regulations as they see fit.

As for "taking" 10 meters, the FCC can reassign ANY frequency allocation in the USA that is not controlled by the NTIA. If you doubt this just look at that missing chunk of the 220MHz band that USED to be allocated to amateur radio.

As for the ITU ultimately controlling the spectrum through treaties - the ITU had no power to force the broadcasters to relocate on the 40 meter band - they recommended it, the countries signed on to the recommendation, but in the end it was entirely up to the broadcasters to relocate or not.

Out of nothing more than international goodwill, the FCC should try not to reallocate any band in a way that would cause interference to other users, but they are still free to do so if they see fit.

Every single hz that we have the PRIVILEGE to use is susceptible to being reallocated to another service at any time.
 
THAT is about the simplest and best way of saying it that I've heard in a long, long time. It doesn't mean you have to 'like it', but it's the way it is.

- 'Doc
 
The FCC are the enforcers of communications law in the USA. While they do not make the laws, they are free to implement regulations as they see fit.

As for "taking" 10 meters, the FCC can reassign ANY frequency allocation in the USA that is not controlled by the NTIA. If you doubt this just look at that missing chunk of the 220MHz band that USED to be allocated to amateur radio.

As for the ITU ultimately controlling the spectrum through treaties - the ITU had no power to force the broadcasters to relocate on the 40 meter band - they recommended it, the countries signed on to the recommendation, but in the end it was entirely up to the broadcasters to relocate or not.

Out of nothing more than international goodwill, the FCC should try not to reallocate any band in a way that would cause interference to other users, but they are still free to do so if they see fit.

Every single hz that we have the PRIVILEGE to use is susceptible to being reallocated to another service at any time.


Almost right. They still have to comply with the Administrative Procedures Act and their authority is limited to areas authorized by Congress.
 

dxChat
Help Users
  • No one is chatting at the moment.