Following on from the strictly AI thread over here > Artificial Intelligence I thought it might be interesting to see what insight using AI can do for the hobbyist/weekend solder jockey or even the experienced Tech who wants to begin to get all the info in 1 place so to speak. That's not to say the following is factually correct or completely wrong. its a exercise in a relevant aspect of our hobby with AI. What I'm hoping for is feedback from the life of experience from the people in the know as far a RF engineering and CB/Amateur Radio techs and others.
I spent a little more time (probably still not enough) thinking about the specific radio (Adams PC-346AA), the documentation I already had accumulated over the years and how to produce a outcome that was helpful from AI.
Caveat: I have used my subscription to M365 Co-Pilot to produce this, you can use any AI of course but consider things like limits to amount and size of uploaded documents/files.
If this peaks the interest of the community that's great if not, well it might come in handy to someone.
Note the files I uploaded to AI:
Adams Service Manual,
Uniden Export manual,
Secret CB Volume 13 & Vol 18,
Master Mods volumes,
Unit 399's 858 documentation from the last iteration of the website before it went.
lbcomms thread from CBtricks that I had a posted previously regarding the 858 chassis.
So the ask was as follows:
What is the best way to broadband the receiver in my President Adams CB Radio with board PC-346AA? Also include important service bullitins or improvment modifications that have good documented outcomes and are regarded as nessasary. Also use information relvant to the Uniden udp858 chassis.
Please act as an experienced RF engineer and pay particular attention to https://cbtricks.org/radios/ , https://www.worldwidedx.com/forums/, https://www.transmission1.net/viewforum.php?f=38 and https://www.rigpix.com/cbfreeband/president_adams.htm .
Seek out posts by user/contributors with names like lbcomms, nomad radio, Unit 399 but do not limit to these contributors alone. Reference the attached files, Adams Service Manual, Uniden Export manual, Secret CB Volume 13 Vol 18, Master Mods volumes, and the additinal files i have included from Unit 399 and a forum thread of lbcomms documentation but do not limit your search to these alone.
Provide analysis of your findings that show real world effective modifications and considerations and call out any myths or unproven outcomes. Also advise if there are any publications or documents that will help you with these tasks.
The first AI response was:
I reponded:
C, B, C
AI Reasoning:
The resulting AI reasoning began as below (This takes time, sometimes you get some of the response while it continues to update other times it will just remind you its working on it).
30 Steps of reasoning below. As you'll see some tools weren't available to me/my AI at the time, I could try to resolve that but haven't. The below i fell is no less impressive as a reasoning process all the same.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The attached President Adams CB Radio Modifications.pdf is the output. Its 11 pages and will spell out the obvious to some of course but also cites where it got it from where it can and links to it.
Also, as I asked it to it asks for 9 other files/documents or access at the end of the attached response, to help further refine.
1. President Adams/Homer factory service manual — highest priority; it supplies the true PC-346 alignment order, board layouts, voltages and parts cross-reference. A downloadable English manual is indexed at Benson’s archive.
I have this already and could add to the AI.
2. Sams CB-176 — Adams-specific photographic servicing, voltage charts and alignment. RigPix identifies CB-176 as the Adams Photofact.
I don't have a clean copy of this, can anyone help?
3. Secret CB correction/troubleshooting page — the CBTricks model index lists “Adams (858 SSB) Trouble Shooting” and “Adams Error In Sams CB-176” in Volume 21, page 40, not Volume 18 page 37. Recheck the supplied page citation before relying on it.
I could include Volume 21, Page 40 as I have it.
4. Cobra 138XLR/139XLR manuals and original bulletins 1208–1216 — best for production-change history, but translate by topology, never designator alone. [cbtricks.org]
Don't have. can anyone help with attachements?
5. Realistic TRC-449/457/458 factory manuals — particularly useful because they document voltage/test-point behaviour and known population differences.
I have the TRC-449 & 458 Service Manuals, so can include.
6. President Grant/Washington/Madison uPD858 documentation — useful comparators only where the PCB generation and circuit nodes match.
Don't have. can anyone help with attachements?
7. Master Mods Volumes 2 and 3 — valuable historical leads, but distinguish TX L37 work from receiver work and verify every change against PC-346AA.
Have these, just didn't specify which ones to seek out, this shows the issue with picture pdf's
8. Unit 399’s complete archived HTML/PDF — useful field experience; the current forum archive notes that the HTML copy is more complete than one PDF transcription.
Pretty sure I have it as that so can include.
9. A receiver-measurement reference covering noise figure, SINAD, two-signal blocking, intermodulation and swept-filter measurement. This is the missing discipline that converts “sounds louder” modifications into defensible results.
So not sure about this one?? is it looking for something it can't find in the service manual or real world input from tech who have trodden this road before? NOT SURE, Anyone?
I spent a little more time (probably still not enough) thinking about the specific radio (Adams PC-346AA), the documentation I already had accumulated over the years and how to produce a outcome that was helpful from AI.
Caveat: I have used my subscription to M365 Co-Pilot to produce this, you can use any AI of course but consider things like limits to amount and size of uploaded documents/files.
If this peaks the interest of the community that's great if not, well it might come in handy to someone.
Note the files I uploaded to AI:
Adams Service Manual,
Uniden Export manual,
Secret CB Volume 13 & Vol 18,
Master Mods volumes,
Unit 399's 858 documentation from the last iteration of the website before it went.
lbcomms thread from CBtricks that I had a posted previously regarding the 858 chassis.
So the ask was as follows:
What is the best way to broadband the receiver in my President Adams CB Radio with board PC-346AA? Also include important service bullitins or improvment modifications that have good documented outcomes and are regarded as nessasary. Also use information relvant to the Uniden udp858 chassis.
Please act as an experienced RF engineer and pay particular attention to https://cbtricks.org/radios/ , https://www.worldwidedx.com/forums/, https://www.transmission1.net/viewforum.php?f=38 and https://www.rigpix.com/cbfreeband/president_adams.htm .
Seek out posts by user/contributors with names like lbcomms, nomad radio, Unit 399 but do not limit to these contributors alone. Reference the attached files, Adams Service Manual, Uniden Export manual, Secret CB Volume 13 Vol 18, Master Mods volumes, and the additinal files i have included from Unit 399 and a forum thread of lbcomms documentation but do not limit your search to these alone.
Provide analysis of your findings that show real world effective modifications and considerations and call out any myths or unproven outcomes. Also advise if there are any publications or documents that will help you with these tasks.
The first AI response was:
- When you say “broadband the receiver,” do you mean A) flatten/extend RF receive sensitivity across the expanded uPD858 tuning range (for example roughly 26–28 MHz), B) widen the receiver’s audio/IF bandwidth, or C) both?
- Should I cover A) receiver/front-end improvements only, or B) the complete PC-346AA/uPD858 restoration and improvement package, including known reliability fixes, PLL/VCO range, clarifier, noise blanker, AGC, transmit-chain service bulletins, and alignment considerations?
- For modification recommendations, should I prioritize A) maximum practical performance, B) preservation/reversibility and factory-like performance, or C) give both approaches and rank each modification by evidence, benefit, risk, and reversibility?
I reponded:
C, B, C
AI Reasoning:
The resulting AI reasoning began as below (This takes time, sometimes you get some of the response while it continues to update other times it will just remind you its working on it).
30 Steps of reasoning below. As you'll see some tools weren't available to me/my AI at the time, I could try to resolve that but haven't. The below i fell is no less impressive as a reasoning process all the same.
Beginning research
Starting to pull together relevant sourcesPlanning extensive research
I am preparing to conduct comprehensive research by initiating web searches alongside enterprise-supplied files and exploring the possibility of using diagrams, considering tool limitations.Formulating search queries
I am creating concise search queries, aiming for 6-8 diverse web queries and around 4 queries with titles for office files, while noting the lack of attachment IDs.Organising next actions
I am planning to prioritise the top three relevant offices and look into specific references. I will ensure to open and click on the designated links efficiently.Researching detailed queries
I am planning to conduct an in-depth search for specific documents related to the Adams service manual and several other technical bulletins, requiring distinct queries and focused web searches.Selecting top references
Focusing on the three most relevant search results and opening specific office references to gather necessary details efficiently.Searching for service manuals
I am focusing on locating the exact contents of service manuals, emphasizing the use of specific URLs and relevant search strategies to retrieve necessary files and bulletins.Selecting relevant options
I’m identifying the top three relevant choices to click on, considering options 5026, 5208, and 5016 for more information on the service manual.Searching for service bulletins
Exploring additional service bulletins beyond 1208A, including patterns and details for Unit399 modifications. Considering various document types such as PDFs and datasheets for specific components.Executing parallel searches
Initiating multiple clicks and find operations simultaneously to enhance the efficiency of the research process.Searching for mod details
Looking to find specific details about the sensitivity mod for Unit399, possibly through direct PDF attachments and relevant bulletins.Considering download options
Exploring ways to download a service manual, including using direct URLs and possible wget commands, while navigating some restrictions on clicking and searching links.Searching for service data
Looking to obtain exact board service data by querying specific phrases from the manual text to generate OCR snippets and identify relevant sources.Considering diagram creation
I am evaluating ways to create a diagram despite the absence of the image_gen tool. It's crucial to adhere to the instructions, so I may use pyexec for a chart or a textual flow representation.Searching for specifications
I am considering more research regarding insulators and grounding, particularly focusing on the applicability of specific components in the Adams schematic. I'll evaluate available resources for verification.Exploring diagram options
Looking for ways to generate a required schematic diagram. Image_gen tool isn't available, but considering alternatives like pyexec or Mermaid for educational illustrations.Investigating report requirements
Planning to deeply investigate the signal path by using a schematic and possibly downloading original PDFs. Considering using wget to access files and perform OCR for high-resolution analysis.Considering diagram creation
Exploring the possibility of generating a diagram using pyexec, as the required image_gen tool is unavailable. I'm contemplating creating a chart or block architecture diagram with matplotlib.Planning further research
Deciding to conduct further research before embedding images, I plan to look into results related to Transmission1 and the cbtricks forum for relevant information.Considering visualization options
Exploring alternatives for creating a visual element in a report due to the unavailability of the image_gen tool, including using pyexec to produce diagrams or HTML visuals.Creating diagram and searching files
Planning to generate a simplified path diagram using grounded data via pyexec, while considering the potential need to locate attachments and searching specifically for file names related to "Master Mods Volume 2".Exploring options for diagrams
I’m evaluating potential methods for generating a required educational diagram, but the preferred tool is unavailable. Alternatives may include using textual Mermaid or other options, though they might not completely meet the needs.Assessing citation and diagram options
I’m considering how to structure citations based on web sources since line numbers for enterprise citations are unavailable. Additionally, I'm exploring ways to present the mechanism details without the required diagram tool, while also planning to organize the report with necessary circuit details and citations.Analyzing signal path and modifications
I’m mapping the signal path through the unit, assessing various components' functions, and considering potential modifications around specific resistors. I am also investigating diode implications for detection and AGC thresholds while ensuring accuracy without overclaiming.Determining circuit modifications and documentation
I’m evaluating circuit component specifications and potential modifications based on existing service bulletins. Additionally, I'm organizing necessary documentation and addressing user requests while ensuring accurate citations and clear recommendations.Clarifying citation requirements
Identifying the need for a detailed document under 4380 words with specific citation requirements, structured information, and the inclusion of various elements such as diagrams, bulletins, and measurements.Examining schematic details
Exploring the receiver path and specific components based on OCR from the schematic, discussing configurations, potential adjustments, and the relationship between frequencies and components in the system.Correcting schematic misunderstandings
Clarifying the roles of various components like L1/L2, D10-D16, and FT1 in the receiver path while addressing the risk of overstating their functions. Discussing necessary modifications and confirming the need for accurate designator verification from schematics.Emphasizing maintenance and reliability
Highlighting the necessity of maintaining older radio equipment by replacing specific components, ensuring proper grounding, and addressing potential relay issues. Discussing detailed modifications and the need for meticulous verification of existing designs and service documents.Outlining receiver path details
Examining the receiver component arrangement, including the antenna, amplifiers, filters, and detectors, while addressing potential modifications. Discussing the importance of verifying component presence, alignment, and bulletins without assuming specifics.-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The attached President Adams CB Radio Modifications.pdf is the output. Its 11 pages and will spell out the obvious to some of course but also cites where it got it from where it can and links to it.
Also, as I asked it to it asks for 9 other files/documents or access at the end of the attached response, to help further refine.
1. President Adams/Homer factory service manual — highest priority; it supplies the true PC-346 alignment order, board layouts, voltages and parts cross-reference. A downloadable English manual is indexed at Benson’s archive.
I have this already and could add to the AI.
2. Sams CB-176 — Adams-specific photographic servicing, voltage charts and alignment. RigPix identifies CB-176 as the Adams Photofact.
I don't have a clean copy of this, can anyone help?
3. Secret CB correction/troubleshooting page — the CBTricks model index lists “Adams (858 SSB) Trouble Shooting” and “Adams Error In Sams CB-176” in Volume 21, page 40, not Volume 18 page 37. Recheck the supplied page citation before relying on it.
I could include Volume 21, Page 40 as I have it.
4. Cobra 138XLR/139XLR manuals and original bulletins 1208–1216 — best for production-change history, but translate by topology, never designator alone. [cbtricks.org]
Don't have. can anyone help with attachements?
5. Realistic TRC-449/457/458 factory manuals — particularly useful because they document voltage/test-point behaviour and known population differences.
I have the TRC-449 & 458 Service Manuals, so can include.
6. President Grant/Washington/Madison uPD858 documentation — useful comparators only where the PCB generation and circuit nodes match.
Don't have. can anyone help with attachements?
7. Master Mods Volumes 2 and 3 — valuable historical leads, but distinguish TX L37 work from receiver work and verify every change against PC-346AA.
Have these, just didn't specify which ones to seek out, this shows the issue with picture pdf's
8. Unit 399’s complete archived HTML/PDF — useful field experience; the current forum archive notes that the HTML copy is more complete than one PDF transcription.
Pretty sure I have it as that so can include.
9. A receiver-measurement reference covering noise figure, SINAD, two-signal blocking, intermodulation and swept-filter measurement. This is the missing discipline that converts “sounds louder” modifications into defensible results.
So not sure about this one?? is it looking for something it can't find in the service manual or real world input from tech who have trodden this road before? NOT SURE, Anyone?
Attachments
Last edited: