I think it might have something to do with the distance of the DX.
Several years ago, somewhere on this site, someone was talking about this, but with AM. They were saying that the scratchy overmodulation seems to go away with distance.
I run a Cobra 148 as a dedicated station monitor, with headphones and no antenna. I can tell that the comp style amplifiers I have need more bias. I think.
Listening to my Stryker 955 on an Xforce 4 pill, I can hear the scratch on SSB. DX reports say it sounds great, and this is from people I know would tell me if it didn't. The radio by it self sounds just as clear as AM.
My Icom 718 with power turned down into a Carl built 4 pill is the same way. DX reports are great, Station monitor says otherwise.
The only setup that sounds correct with an amp is my President Madison with a Texas Star DX500 putting out about 350w.
This has always made me wonder if I should try to make my other setups sound like the Madison and DX500? But if it sounds good on the far end, do I really need to?
Anyone else use a separate radio with headphones to monitor?